Make in India: Why are we struggling?

- Advertisement -

What ails domestic manufacturing in the Indian electronics industry, and how do we overcome these obstacles? Here are some insights.

By Srinivasa Moorthy S.A.

Having worked in India throughout my career, at various organisations including C-DOT (which changed the profile of the Indian telecom industry), I had hoped that the Make in India programme would succeed at least in the Indian electronics industry, as it had in the case of the Indian auto industry. However, that doesn’t seem to be happening, yet.

- Advertisement -

Recently, I happened to be in Shanghai as well as in Shenzhen to source 17.78cm tablets (remember, importing a tablet and paying duty works out cheaper than making it in India).
My stay was a revelation! We decided to meet three vendors—one for plastics, one for electronics and the last one for the battery. The experience I had was amazing.

The plastic vendor’s infrastructure was as good as any I have seen in India, so I wondered why we are not able to get things done here. What I noticed was the attitude of the vendor. He made himself very clear, regarding the terms of business, and did not query us about the volumes at all. He clearly put forth his conditions— he would do the tooling and supply the plastics, but was not interested in the business if we wanted him to do only one of those tasks. Second, he named his price based on the volume. In India, this is never possible. Vendors will first ask you how many thousands you will buy, even before trying to understand what needs to be done.

Interestingly, I did get an Indian vendor for a different plastic part in this model, who was willing to work with me on the basis that we would scale up volume as we went along. You will be surprised to know that he was able to get us tooling for a price that was just as cheap as any Chinese vendor, and plastics at a price that was 60 per cent lower than the existing vendor. But the effort I had to put in to work with him was the same as when working with a Chinese vendor.

We discovered that with electronics too, the Chinese solutions house (as they call themselves!) would do the design only if we committed to also buying the assembled electronics from them. The firm’s turnaround time was a few weeks. Having been in the design services business, I realised that unless your design is back-ended with manufacturing, pure design services will never succeed. I have experienced this when I was heading an engineering design organisation of an EMS vendor.

In India, we try to do these connected things, separately, which leads to failure. So-called EMS providers in India are assembly houses or can take up mature products, but they are very weak in the vendor development process. Having worked in C-DOT, I know the difference between supply chain and vendor development. India’s automobile industry succeeded primarily due to its vendor development process and supply chain process. In India, especially in electronics, this is a big gap that needs to be filled.

The government has listened to the industry and slapped punitive taxes on imported finished goods, but unless the back-end is fixed, this move is not going to make any difference. There is no concerted incentive mechanism for manufacturing basic electronic components. I was involved with a potential investor in setting up a multi-layer PCB plant. While the investment was in the range of ` 7 billion (US$ 100 million approximately), the investor’s main request was for the government to set up a common effluent treatment plant (ETP) for the industrial estate, as pollution is a big issue in the PCB industry. Those in the concerned government department never understood the importance of this, but kept on asking the company to commit to making the investment, which without the ETP plant could never have taken off! Eventually, the company lost interest and shelved the plan for the plant.

What I realise is that if Make in India has to succeed, the ecosystem is critical. By ecosystem, what I mean is the essential common infrastructure that has to be provided by the government. The best examples that prove my point are Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra. In these states, when they start a new industrial area, they get the basics in place even before they start promoting the project. Most other states have never done this. Just offering land alone will never meet the needs of manufacturers.

There are two essentials in the electronics field that need to be heavily subsidised for Make in India to succeed—the manufacturing of printed circuit boards, and the development of lithium-ion battery technology. Tax holidays are also needed for extended periods till the industry stabilises. Unless this is done, Make in India will never succeed, at least in the case of the Indian electronics industry.

- Advertisement -

Most Popular Articles

Force Motors Goes Global And Enters EV Market

0
The manufacturer of vans and utility vehicles has hired E&Y to assist with business restructuring and the digital transformation of its entire value chain....

Tessolve Acquires German Chip Firm With ₹4B To Expand Global Reach

0
Ramping up AI, automotive, and data centre chip design to lead the semiconductor race, Hero Electronix subsidiary Tessolve aims to boost its global edge...
Samsung Chip

Samsung Shifts Strategy, Set To Quit LED Business

0
Following disappointing financial results and a loss of market edge, Samsung is exiting the LED business by 2030, shifting its focus to more 'promising'...

Hero MotoCorp To Launch Vida Electric Two-Wheeler In Europe And UK

0
Hero MotoCorp revealed its intention to enter the European and UK markets with its electric vehicle line, Vida, commencing in late 2025. At the...

China Challenges EU Electric Vehicle Tariffs At WTO

0
Last month, the European bloc declared that it would impose import tariffs as high as 35% on Chinese electric vehicles, claiming that these exports...

“Adoption Of IoT-Enabled SMT Machines Is Still In Early Phases” – Pradeep Tandon, Director...

0
While electronics are becoming smarter through the Internet of Things, is electronics manufacturing following suit? Pradeep Tandon, Director for India, Middle East, and SAARC...
Dr Yashodhan P. Gokhale, Vice President for Battery Technology, JSW Energy

Charge Forward: High-Voltage Batteries And MSMEs Can Fuel India’s EV Revolution

0
A nuanced explanation of low- and high-voltage EV batteries by Dr Gokhale, Vice President for Battery Technology at JSW Energy, illuminates their advancements and...
Sanjay Gupta, CDO & Global Head of Engineering, L&T Semiconductor Technologies

Can MSMEs Contribute And Profit From The Semicon Boom?

0
Semiconductor manufacturing often requires significant investment, typically feasible only for governments or large corporations. But are there opportunities for MSMEs as well? We spoke...
N.P. Ramesh, COO and Co-Founder, Orb Energy

“We Ensured Customers’ Monthly EMI Would Be Equal To Or Less Than Their Electricity...

0
In a conversation with Nitisha from EFY, N.P. Ramesh of Orb Energy outlines the early financing challenges customers faced. He explains how Orb Energy’s...

“Government Policy Should Equitably Address All Electric Vehicles: Extend Subsidies To Retrofits Or Remove...

0
Aryaman Raghuvanshi from EFY engages with Pramod Narendra, Head of Brand Management and Retail Network at Starya Mobility, to explore the overlooked potential of...

Wireless Light-Based Communication With Velmenni’s Technology

0
Velmenni is at the forefront of wireless communication innovation with its pioneering light-based technologies, Li-Fi and LC Link. Founded by Deepak Solanki in October 2014...

Harnessing AI Technology For Efficient Pest Management

0
AI-Genix, an agri-tech startup, is transforming pest management for farmers through advanced AI-enabled systems that precisely target harmful pests. In an industry where pesticides and...

One Charger To Charge All Your Devices

0
Now, there is no need to carry different chargers for different products. This Bhubaneswar startup has launched a universal 65W charger using GaN technology...

Karnataka Government Initiative Promises ₹5M To Tech Startups

0
Boosting innovation and entrepreneurship across the state’s vibrant ecosystem, Karnataka launched Elevate 2024 and KAN, offering grants up to ₹5 million for startups. On Tuesday,...

CastNX Tech Startup Secures ₹232M For Power Electronics Growth

0
Eyeing to boost R&D and produce 100,000 variable frequency drives by 2026, Indian power electronics startup CastNX has secured ₹232.2 million from Plutus Investments. CastNX...

Industry's Buzz

Learn From Leaders

Startups